Matt Dillon

I Play Rocky

11/11/2026

Cineworld, Edinburgh

We all love an underdog story – and this true-life account of how the most famous boxing movie in history was created is the very essence of what we mean by that term.

It’s the early 70s and wannabe actor ‘Mike’ Stallone (Anthony Ippolito) is making ends meet doing a series of nondescript jobs in and around New York City. In his free time he grabs every opportunity to attend auditions for minor character roles such as Thug No 3. When he gets desperate enough, he even dips his toes into the waters of soft porn, though that lucrative career path is quickly abandoned as soon as his bills are paid.

One job has him tearing ticket stubs in a movie theatre and it’s here that he meets Sasha (AnnaSophia Robb), who soon becomes his significant other. She persuades Mike to switch back to his real name, Sylvester – so much better for the movie star he longs to be, she tells him. Sasha is even introduced to Sylvester’s father, Frank (Matt Dillon), a hairdresser by trade and an opinionated asshole by nature. Frank never misses an opportunity to criticise his son, who he believes doesn’t have a hope in hell of ever landing a proper film role. “You’re just not handsome enough,” Frank insists.

But, nurtured by Sasha’s absolute belief in him, Sylvester refuses to give up. Inspired by a boxing match he sees on TV between Muhammad Ali and a much older boxer called Chuck Hepner, he pens the screenplay for Rocky in just three days and even manages to get a couple of bigshot producers, Irwin Winkler (P J Byrne) and Robert Chartoff (Toby Kebbell), interested in the script. They take it to money-man Sandy Maddox (Tracy Letts) to ask him to come up with the necessary finance, a cool two million at a time when that was considered big money. He’s happy to be involved in the project provided they can get a star name to take on the lead role. Ryan O’Neal or Clint Eastwood, maybe? Somebody like that.

But Sly is determined to take the lead and, no matter how much money he’s offered to step aside – and as the months pass, he is being offered big bucks – he stubbornly sticks to his guns…

Of course, a concept like this can only work if the actor playing Stallone is credible – and Ippolito does an extraordinary job with the role, delivering a really convincing impersonation of the man, nailing that unmistakable gravel-toned voice, while at the same time, giving us insights into Stallone’s character and what drove that stubborn determination to succeed. Peter Farrelly directs Pete Gamble’s script with genuine verve and the 70s period detail is faithfully reproduced, right down to the early steadicam shots used to capture Rocky Balboa’s iconic victory ascent up the steps of the Philadelphia Museum of Art.

If there’s an issue with I Play Rocky, it’s simply this – how can the makers ever hope to surprise an audience with a story that’s so universally familiar? Okay, occasionally I encounter a few things that I didn’t previously know, but they are few and far between. On the other hand, I cannot deny that I really enjoy the mid-credit sequences, where short scenes from the original film are uncannily reproduced in tiny detail. Is this film, like its illustrious predecessor, likely to win an Oscar? Ippolito seems a good bet to get a best actor nomination and, should he end up lifting the gong on the big night, it will feel suspiciously like history repeating itself.

But I’m not convinced that this film has the necessary clout to win by a knockout.

4 Stars

Philip Caveney

Capone

03/03/21

Netflix

Al Capone is perhaps the best known gangster in American history. He’s been the subject of many films and portrayed by a whole host of celebrated actors; perhaps most famously by Paul Muni in Scarface and by Robert De Niro in The Untouchables. But he’s never been depicted as he is in Josh Trank’s downbeat film.

Capone is set in the dog days, towards the end of the gangster’s life. ‘Fonse’ has recently been released from prison and is suffering horribly from the neuro syphilis that has plagued him since his teens. Locked up in a palatial mansion somewhere in Florida, with devoted wife Mae (Linda Cardellini) at his side, and with regular visits from Doctor Karlock (Kyle MacLachlan), he regularly falls prey to vivid hallucinations that take him back to revisit experiences from his bloody hey day – from visits to booze-fuelled jazz clubs to crawling across heaps of bloodied bodies after a massacre he’s orchestrated.

Fonse no longer knows what is real and what is illusion and, unfortunately, this also extends to viewers of the film. While it might sound like a promising conceit on paper, it’s actually infuriating, particularly when the screenplay (also by Trank) refuses to stick to any kind of internal logic. I’m fine when I’m seeing odd happenings from Capone’s point of view, but what about when they are apparently witnessed by some of the other characters in the story? Is Capone’s old pal Johnny (Matt Dillon) actually still alive or just a vivid memory from the past? And who is the mysterious kid who keeps phoning Fonse from Cleveland? While I don’t insist that every loose end needs to be tied up, too much here is simply left hanging.

Hardy is generally a gifted performer but he’s saddled here with a thankless central role that offers him little chance to shine. Swaddled in some pretty unconvincing makeup, with a cigar (or a carrot) clenched relentlessly between his teeth, his dialogue is rarely more than a series of grunts and incoherent curses. He’s actually more eloquent when he’s noisily filling one of the oversized nappies he’s forced to wear, after suffering a few malodorous accidents in bed. Also… his constantly stoned expression makes him look a dead ringer for a grumpier version of Bernard Bresslaw from the ‘Carry On’ films.

The film’s one hour and forty-seven minutes’ duration consequently unfolds at a funereal pace, with very little in the way of progression. I feel rather like I am stuck in a traffic jam, trying to figure out what little I can see through the windscreen, and constantly wondering when I might be moving onwards again. I stick with it to the bitter end, but really have to force myself.

There’s probably a fascinating film to be made about the end of Capone’s life but, sadly, this isn’t it. Josh Trank probably had a coherent vision for his film; somehow it’s been lost in the mix.

2.5 stars

Philip Caveney