Three Birds


21/11/26

Viewforth, Edinburgh

We’re meeting friends for dinner and, with these particular pals, it’s become a bit of a thing to try somewhere new each time we get together. All too aware of my apparently worsening intolerance, I type ‘best Edinburgh restaurants for gluten free’ into the search bar and sit back to see what comes up. Top of the list is Three Birds, a mere stone’s throw away from us in Bruntsfield. The kitchen is described as ‘mostly gluten free’ and, in fact, it’s only the sourdough bread (‘kept separate from everything else’) that contains the offending proteins. Woo hoo! I’ve got the whole menu to choose from!

The small, twenty-eight cover bistro is busy, so – despite booking two weeks ahead – we have to settle for an unfashionably early 5.15pm time-slot. No matter: the wintry darkness makes afternoons feel like evenings anyway, so it’s easy to delude ourselves that it’s way later than it really is. It helps that the tables around us are full, creating a lively, convivial atmosphere.

Our waiter is friendly and engaging, making us feel very welcome. It’s an auspicious start. But is the food any good?

Thankfully, yes.

I start with a beetroot gnocchi, served with apple, walnuts and a vegan blue cheese sauce, while Philip opts for a prawn and crab cocktail, with gem lettuce, avocado, ginger beer mayo and pickled ginger. They’re both lovely, but his has the edge: it’s light and tangy and the addition of ginger is inspired. One of our friends has the smoked ham hock terrine, which he says is great, while the other just has some sourdough bread.

For his main course, Philip has one of tonight’s specials, a venison haunch with crushed potatoes and hispi cabbage. it’s delicious, the meat served rare and tender as you like. My confit duck leg comes with a cornucopia of tasty additions, namely Morteau sausage, a puy lentil and radicchio cassoulet, mustard crème fraiche, damson puree, fine beans and crispy onions. It’s a complex mix and it works really well, making for a most satisfying meal. Our friends fancy fish tonight, so they both have roast cod fillet with a hazelnut herb crust, which comes with artichokes, tender stem broccoli and parmesan potato wedges.

Predictably – I have a very sweet tooth – I’m most excited about the puddings. Since going gluten-free, I’ve found dessert menus especially limiting. But here I can reject a whole host of delectable-sounding treats – ‘Bounty mess,’ pumpkin cake, lemon drizzle trifle – in favour of some rocky road with peanut butter and jam ice cream. In fact, three of us order this (one of our friends is too full, and opts for a couple of scoops of ice cream instead). The flavours complement each other perfectly, and it’s a lovely way to end the meal.

Two hours pass quickly, and we soon find ourselves outside on the street, hugging our friends goodbye and promising not to leave it so long next time. We’ve had a delightful evening, and now we’re full and tired, ready to go home and relax before bed.

So what if it’s only 7.30pm?

4.6 stars

Susan Singfield

You Can See Everything

21/11/26

Cineworld, Edinburgh

You Can See Everything – a nearly three hour long documentary co-directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim – has enjoyed a seismic release in America, where audiences were virtually fighting for tickets. Made on a modest budget of around seven million dollars, it has already taken in excess of $100 million and that figure keeps rising. While it might not be quite as cataclysmic an event in the UK, the big auditorium where we watch it on a cold Saturday morning is nevertheless three-quarters full, which suggests that people here are taking notice too.

Fielder, best known for his spoof television shows and weird drama series, The Curse, receives a telephone call from one Billy Evans, the husband of disgraced Theranos CEO Elizabeth Holmes, who is fast approaching the time when she must head off to prison to serve an eleven-year sentence for fraud. For those who don’t know, Theranos was a healthcare innovation based around an iPhone-sized medical gadget which, Holmes claimed, could detect all kinds of illnesses from a single drop of blood. It received millions of dollars from potential investors, the only problem being that, well… it didn’t actually work. Which was awkward to say the very least. (Interested parties who know nothing of the story might want to investigate the excellent Apple TV biopic, The Dropout, where Holmes’ rise and fall is brilliantly portrayed by Amanda Seyfried.)

Evans suggests that Fielder might like to move in to the seafront apartment where he, his wife and their two young children are currently spending their time as Holmes readies herself for her imminent incarceration. Fielder and his film crew, Evans promises, will have access to every aspect of the couple’s lives. They will indeed be able to ‘see everything.’

The result is frankly mesmerising. Holmes maintains a wide-eyed, grinning demeanour throughout, insisting that she has done nothing wrong and even claiming that she has never told a lie in her entire life. Evans, a professed fan of Charlie Kirk, has the manipulative, controlling air of a man intent on creating his own egocentric narrative and is a little too ready to expose every aspect of himself – including a sequence where he takes a long shower. And Fielder meanwhile has the confused air of someone trapped in the midst of an enigma, asking wince-inducing questions and watching suspiciously from dark corners as he hopelessly attempts to get a handle on what really happened with the Theranos debacle.

The abiding sense of menace is astutely heightened by Ali Balouzian’s oppressive musical score and Oppenheim manages to give the enterprise the same forbidding tone that he used in his recent release, Primetime, imbuing the proceedings with the heft of a compelling crime mystery.

And then Holmes goes to prison, which you might think would signal the end of the project – but instead, two years after her departure, Fielder adopts a meta approach to the project, recreating scenes and using actors to embody characters he no longer has access to – and an already compelling story edges into the realms of a baffling riddle. The film raises questions about the nature of the documentary genre itself – including who should profit from it – and that three-hour run time seems to positively flash by.

Is Holmes guilty of fraud – or is she just a compliant stooge, manipulated into the hot seat to take the rap for another domineering man, her then partner Sunny Balwani, who is also languishing in jail?

You Can See Everything will have you discussing the baffling questions it raises long after you’ve left the cinema. The latest talk is that it’s being hotly-tipped for an Oscar and I won’t be one bit surprised if that comes to pass. Whatever the outcome, this is unmissable cinema at its most thought-provoking.

5 stars

Philip Caveney

Pride and Prejudice

19/11/2026

Norton Park Conference Centre, Edinburgh

It is a truth universally acknowledged that Pride and Prejudice is a comedy – though I’ve rarely seen that fact as boldly expressed as it is in this sprightly production from Union Theatre. Kate Hamill’s adaptation of Jane Austen’s most celebrated novel finds the humour in the piece and plays it to the max.

From its opening scene, director Hannah Fitzpatrick nails the anarchic nature of the Bennet household, overseen by a delightfully unfettered performance from Hazel Eadie as Mrs B, striving ever more frantically to find suitable husbands for her ‘ageing’ daughters. Lucy Hagen Walker is wonderfully sardonic as Lizzy – and how refreshing to see a Lydia (Hannah Rudge) who actually convinces as the unpredictable fourteen-year-old of the book. Erin Flanagan (as Jane) is quietly impressive as the most eligible of the daughters, while Mary (Kate Stephenson) is portrayed as a saxophone-playing, black-clad goth, who towers over the rest of the cast, startling (and irritating) everyone she encounters.

There’s an interesting gender-fluid approach to the piece. Keegan Siebken impresses in dual roles as the dastardly Mr Wickham and Lizzy’s bestie, Charlotte Lucas, while Calum Rosie does a hilarious turn as Miss Bingley, managing to make even the simple act of sipping tea wildly suggestive. Catriona Bone McNeill’s performance as both an enthusiastically puppyish Mr Bingley and a truly intimidating Lady Catherine is very accomplished. The scene where she’s accompanied by a bizarrely veiled Miss De Bourgh (Stephenson, again) is a comic highlight.

Of course there has to be a Mr Darcy and Jimmy Kavanagh (last seen by B&B in an excellent adaptation of Eurydice) captures the man’s cool demeanour with aplomb. The scene where he finally throws aside the veils of convention and plights his love for Lizzy is very nicely done.

I like Fitzpatrick’s adventurous staging, and also Stephenson’s innovative costuming, which has Regency-style pelisses worn over current fashions, aligning each of the characters to a recognisable archetype.

Settling into an extended run at the Norton Park Conference Centre, this vivacious production has much to commend it – and I have to confess, though I’ve seen many enjoyable performances of Pride and Prejudice down the years, I’ve rarely laughed as much as I do tonight.

4 stars

Philip Caveney

Prima Facie

18/11/26

Cineworld, Edinburgh

After the phenomenal success of Suzie Miller’s one-woman play – first in Australia and then in the UK – a film version of Prima Facie was surely inevitable. And here it is, adapted for the big screen by Miller herself, and directed by Susanna White. The central role, played most notably on stage by Jodie Comer, belongs here to Cynthia Erivo. However, instead of a stream-of-consciousness internal monologue, the movie offers us a different view of high-flying young barrister Tessa Ensler. This time, we see her from the outside.

Tessa is a brilliant lawyer, everyone agrees, and her success is all the more impressive if you factor in the odds. Black, female, working-class: people like her are not exactly commonplace at the Bar. She made it to Cambridge on a scholarship by being clever and working hard, and she uses the same winning combo to shine in court. She loves the law and believes wholeheartedly in what she does, seeing herself as a kind of chess Grandmaster. Her role is to outwit her opponents.

If a high percentage of her cases happen to be defending alleged sexual abusers, then that’s just the luck of the draw. It’s not for her to consider their guilt or innocence; it’s not for her to worry about the victims. She has a job to do and she’ll do it well.

But then Tessa is raped by her colleague, Julian (Daniel Ings).

The scales fall from her eyes. She can see now that the legal system she’s devoted her life to is unfit for purpose. She knows the legalistic tricks that will weaken her credibility and acquit her attacker. She knows that, if she presses charges, this is a fight she’ll lose.

She decides to fight it anyway.

Miller’s polemic is just as urgently expressed here as it is in the play I applaud the decision to open out the narrative, introducing other characters and showing us more of Tessa’s private life. Without it, what would be the point? We already have an NT Live recording of the play; the film needs to do something different to earn its place.

I like the juxtaposition of the barrsisters’ chambers with Tessa’s childhood home, the former stately and grand, the latter cluttered and cosy. At first, she seems happier with her workmates than her family, but the system protects its own and Julian’s dad is a high court judge. When the chips are down, it’s Tessa’s mum (Noma Dumezweni) and brother (Toheeb Jimoh) who support her.

Erivo’s performance is every bit as accomplished as you’d expect, imbuing Tessa with poise and determination, as well as a devastating sense of loss. Her final speech is delivered with such passion and intensity it’s impossible to ignore. Meanwhile, Ings’ depiction of the charming, entitled Julian is horribly credible. He’s such a nice guy – until he isn’t.

The movie’s release feels especially apposite, coming in the same month as Russell Brand’s high-profile rape trial, where the celebrity’s defence lawyer used a barrage of rape myths in an attempt to undermine the victims. His tactic didn’t work. Maybe, just maybe, the tide is starting to turn. Maybe Tessa Ensler’s plea for change is finally being heard.

4.3 stars

Susan Singfield

Being Heumann

16/11/26

Apple TV

I’ve never heard of Judith Heumann until I see trailers for Oscar-winning writer-director Siân Heder’s third feature – but I’ve certainly seen the results of her activism: the dropped kerbs, ramps and railings now ubiquitous across America’s public spaces.

Fun fact: dropped kerbs were actually invented by a Brit, one Selwyn Goldsmith, an architect and wheelchair user, who saw them as a simple way to make the streets navigable for more people. Less fun fact: when it came to mandating disability access, the UK lagged behind the USA. Still, where one leads others follow – and Judy Heumann was one determined pioneer.

Of course, those structural modifications are only the tip of the iceberg. Less visible but just as important are the other rights Judy and her crew fought to secure, including access to education, work and independent living. I’d say she was inspiring, but her response to that particular word is well known. “Inspired to do what? Inspired to do something – or just inspired?” Hats off to Heder for eschewing the clichéd inspiration-porn this film’s intrepid protagonist would so clearly have despised.

British actor Ruth Madeley plays Heumann with real heart, imbuing her with a gloriously indomitable charisma. It’s easy to believe in her ability to lead a revolution, rousing support from far and wide – as well as in her ability to piss people off, thanks to her blunt verbal putdowns and unwillingness to compromise. In the end, of course, it’s the combination of these traits that makes her successful. (And no, that’s not a spoiler; it’s a matter of historical record.)

Her beef is with the government’s refusal to ratify Section 504, a modification quietly and anonymously added to the Rehabilitation Act in 1973, mandating nondiscrimination and accessibility for disabled people. Surely this should mean things are more equitable now but it’s 1977 and nothing has changed. Heumann and her fellow activists have had enough. What can they do to make themselves heard?

Whatever it takes.

If banners and peaceful protests aren’t enough, they’ll stop traffic – literally – rolling their wheelchairs into the busy New York streets, forcing lorries and taxis to brake for them. They’ll storm government buildings – oxygen tanks, guide canes and head-pointers notwithstanding. They’ll stage the country’s longest ever sit-in, and form an intersectional coalition with other radical, marginalised groups, including the Black Panthers. Civil rights are for everyone.

The story’s antagonist is the government’s secretary of Health, Education and Welfare (HEW), Joseph Califano (Mark Ruffalo), played here as a harried, over-worked official, fearful of the cost implications. He can see two things clearly: the effects on his budget and on his political career. He’s less bothered about the disabled people whose lives would be altered if he signed – and his ignorance makes it easier for him to disregard their needs. To this end, he refuses to engage with the activists, doing everything he can to shut down their protest without ever listening to them.

But he’s reckoned without Judy…

Heder and Rebekah Taussig’s script celebrates the disabled protestors without sanctifying them, presenting them as flawed and fallible as well as fabulous, as rounded human beings with the same needs and desires as non-disabled people. The sit-in isn’t a virtuous, modest affair. Sure, some of the activists need attendants to help with personal care; that apart, it’s exactly what you’d expect from a group of angry, determined, spirited young folk. There’s singing and dancing; there are squabbles and fights. There’s joy, despair, sex and drugs. More than anything, though, there’s resolve.

The protestors’ testimonies are perhaps the most powerful part of Being Heumann. When the disabled actors speak of how their characters have been disenfranchised – refused teaching licenses because their wheelchairs make them a fire hazard; unable to read because their schools didn’t offer braille – there’s an extra layer of authenticity from their lived experiences. Why is this the first time I’ve seen so many of them on screen? In particular, Madeline Delp, Andrew Pilkington, Charlie Rush-Reese and Rio Finnegan are fine performers; they deserve to be more visible outwith stories like this.

An important reminder of how rights are hard won (and easily lost), Being Heumann is well worth a month’s subscription to Apple TV.

And if it inspires you, make sure that inspiration spurs you to action. WWJD?*

4.3 stars

Susan Singfield

*What would Judy Do?

Six by Nico: American Murder Mystery

12/11/26

Hanover Street, Edinburgh

Our experience of Six by Nico so far has been mixed. During the Covid lockdowns, we enjoyed a couple of their ‘at home’ meals so much that we bought them as gifts for several friends and relatives, certain they’d be well appreciated. When the world opened up again and we were free to visit an actual restaurant, we wasted no time. Sadly, we were disappointed by the Ancient Rome menu we sampled.

A murder mystery though? That’s enough to draw us back in. We’re suckers for a story.

Our waitress, Alex, introduces the concept with enthusiasm, no mean feat considering how often she has to repeat it, service after service, day after day. We order some sparkling water (me) and a 0% Asahi (Phil) and settle down to read the character profiles. Just who are these suspects we’re dealing with?

The premise is simple. We’re in Hollow Creek, a small American town where, thirty years ago, best-selling crime writer Maggie Sawyer was killed. Her husband, Daniel, was convicted of the murder, but new evidence suggests he might be innocent – and it’s up to us to solve the case. With each course, we’re given more information, bringing us closer and closer to discovering the truth. Will we be able to work out whodunnit?

It’s a Thursday lunchtime and, even though it’s just the two of us non-drinkers, we have a lot of fun. I imagine the experience is even more entertaining if you’re out with a larger group for an evening, relishing paired wines and differing opinions.

The first three courses are starters, and we kick off with crispy fried chicken on a buckwheat waffle. I’m expecting to be able to eat this (buckwheat is gluten free) but my chicken comes served on a tater tot instead, so I guess there must be some wheat flour in the waffle mix. The kitchen clearly takes allergies seriously: the coating on my chicken is different from Phil’s too, and there’s a little GF sticker on the plate, which I find reassuring. There’s a smoked bacon dressing, which adds some flavour, but generally we both find this course a little bland. It’s fine. Just not special.

Next up is an ox cheek croquette served with a pumpkin velouté. My croquette comes without the breadcrumb coating, and it’s delicious. The velouté lacks seasoning though, and there’s no salt on the table. We request some and there’s an immediate improvement. What’s more, we get to play with a coloured lens to read a secret message that might help us find the murderer…

For course three, Philip has a Cuban Sandwich, which is a chorizo & smoked ham hough, while I go for the veggie option of goat’s cheese bomba. The food seems to be getting better with each successive course; Philip’s in particular is bold and flavoursome. And there’s another piece of evidence coming our way. We start to theorise about motives.

The fourth dish (the first of two mains) is billed as a clam chowder but it doesn’t look like any chowder I’ve had before. I thought ‘deconstructed’ dishes were considered passé these days, but the concept is alive and kicking here. Nonetheless, the roasted ling is well cooked, and perfectly complemented by a yummy crab bisque.

Coming in at number five is a chicken and wild mushroom casserole. Again, this isn’t so much a casserole as elements-of-a-casserole-arranged-on-a-plate – but there’s no denying how tasty it is. It’s certainly the best thing we’ve eaten so far. And what’s this? A UV light to uncover a hidden clue? Yes please.

Last but not least are the puddings. The maple apple cobbler is an absolute triumph, comprising a gloriously decadent baked apple delice, along with some oat and rye whiskey ice cream for Phil and an apple sorbet for me. Candied pecans add some extra punch (and crunch), and we both find ourselves eating as slowly as we can, trying to make it last as long as possible while we consider the various characters and why they might have killed Maggie.

We fail to identify the killer (we have elaborate theories that come to naught) but the real answer is satisfying. which is what really counts. We console ourselves with an add-on extra dessert: a cherry pop tart soft-serve ice cream. Phil’s comes in a cornet and mine in a bowl, and it’s a refreshing way to end the meal.

All in all, we have a grand old time. The food is decent enough but it’s the game-playing element that makes this work. If you’re looking for something different to entertain you, this American Murder Mystery is sure to hit the spot. But hurry, it ends soon!

4 stars

Susan Singfield

I Play Rocky

11/11/2026

Cineworld, Edinburgh

We all love an underdog story – and this true-life account of how the most famous boxing movie in history was created is the very essence of what we mean by that term.

It’s the early 70s and wannabe actor ‘Mike’ Stallone (Anthony Ippolito) is making ends meet doing a series of nondescript jobs in and around New York City. In his free time he grabs every opportunity to attend auditions for minor character roles such as Thug No 3. When he gets desperate enough, he even dips his toes into the waters of soft porn, though that lucrative career path is quickly abandoned as soon as his bills are paid.

One job has him tearing ticket stubs in a movie theatre and it’s here that he meets Sasha (AnnaSophia Robb), who soon becomes his significant other. She persuades Mike to switch back to his real name, Sylvester – so much better for the movie star he longs to be, she tells him. Sasha is even introduced to Sylvester’s father, Frank (Matt Dillon), a hairdresser by trade and an opinionated asshole by nature. Frank never misses an opportunity to criticise his son, who he believes doesn’t have a hope in hell of ever landing a proper film role. “You’re just not handsome enough,” Frank insists.

But, nurtured by Sasha’s absolute belief in him, Sylvester refuses to give up. Inspired by a boxing match he sees on TV between Muhammad Ali and a much older boxer called Chuck Hepner, he pens the screenplay for Rocky in just three days and even manages to get a couple of bigshot producers, Irwin Winkler (P J Byrne) and Robert Chartoff (Toby Kebbell), interested in the script. They take it to money-man Sandy Maddox (Tracy Letts) to ask him to come up with the necessary finance, a cool two million at a time when that was considered big money. He’s happy to be involved in the project provided they can get a star name to take on the lead role. Ryan O’Neal or Clint Eastwood, maybe? Somebody like that.

But Sly is determined to take the lead and, no matter how much money he’s offered to step aside – and as the months pass, he is being offered big bucks – he stubbornly sticks to his guns…

Of course, a concept like this can only work if the actor playing Stallone is credible – and Ippolito does an extraordinary job with the role, delivering a really convincing impersonation of the man, nailing that unmistakable gravel-toned voice, while at the same time, giving us insights into Stallone’s character and what drove that stubborn determination to succeed. Peter Farrelly directs Pete Gamble’s script with genuine verve and the 70s period detail is faithfully reproduced, right down to the early steadicam shots used to capture Rocky Balboa’s iconic victory ascent up the steps of the Philadelphia Museum of Art.

If there’s an issue with I Play Rocky, it’s simply this – how can the makers ever hope to surprise an audience with a story that’s so universally familiar? Okay, occasionally I encounter a few things that I didn’t previously know, but they are few and far between. On the other hand, I cannot deny that I really enjoy the mid-credit sequences, where short scenes from the original film are uncannily reproduced in tiny detail. Is this film, like its illustrious predecessor, likely to win an Oscar? Ippolito seems a good bet to get a best actor nomination and, should he end up lifting the gong on the big night, it will feel suspiciously like history repeating itself.

But I’m not convinced that this film has the necessary clout to win by a knockout.

4 Stars

Philip Caveney

The Devils

07/11/26

Filmhouse, Edinburgh

I first saw The Devils on its initial release in 1971 at my local cinema in Queensferry, North Wales. I was twenty years old and, although a keen cinema-goer, I had yet to write my first film review. (That came two years later. You can probably guess the title. (Another excellent day for an exorcism.) I had read about The Devils in the press: indeed, I could hardly have missed it. My parents took The Daily Mirror and I can still remember how it warned me to steer well clear of it. It was ‘depraved’ and ‘salacious’ and featured ‘disgusting’ scenes depicting nuns indulging in rampant sexual antics.

Short of offering me free tickets, they couldn’t have got me there any quicker.

Ken Russell’s most controversial film was a searing vision of what can happen when the Catholic Church has total control of a country. From its opening scenes, where King Louis XIII (Graham Armitage) performs his dance interpretation of The Birth of Venus, I was utterly riveted. I remained so throughout its excoriating account of what happened in the walled city of Loudon in 1634 – a story so unrelentingly weird it couldn’t have been invented. It was only much later on I discovered that, in order to gain a cinematic release, the film had been drastically censored. Somewhere out there, those cut scenes still existed on discarded rolls of celluloid – but they were ‘lost.’

After that, things got even more complicated. After a search initiated by film critic Mark Kermode, the censored footage was eventually located by film archivist Tim Everett in the year 2000. So why did it take Warner Brothers another twenty-six years to reinstate them? Whatever the reason, the restored version is finally…. FINALLY here and gazing around a near sold-out Screen One at Edinburgh’s Filmhouse, where a brand new 35mm print of the film is about to be screened, I can only reflect what a tragedy it is that director Ken Russell died in 2011 and is no longer alive to witness this renaissance.

The walled fortress of Loudon is in uproar. Following the quelled Huguenot (Protestant) rebellion and a devastating plague that has killed thousands, French Catholic statesman Cardinal Richelieu (Christopher Logue) attempts to persuade Louis XIII to demolish the fortifications at various cities across France. He want to ensure that any remaining Huguenots can be more easily weeded out and executed. But the King has made a vague promise to the Governor of Loudon that his walls shall remain untouched. That Governor is now dead and the running of the city has fallen to the popular priest, Urbain Grandier (Oliver Reed). Richleau despatches Baron de Loubardement (Dudley Sutton) to take care of the matter, but Grandier, though dissolute and self-aggrandising, refuses to be swayed on the matter.

What Grandier doesn’t realise is that he has a secret admirer. Sister Jeanne des Anges (Vanessa Regrave), the Mother Superior at the city’s nunnery, has long admired him from afar – and, in her solitude, she’s started indulging in bizarre sexual fantasies in which he features prominently. When she discovers that Grandier has secretly wed Madelaine de Brou (Gemma Jones), Jeanne’s anger spills over into madness, causing her to speak openly about her fantasies – and when Baron de Loubardement hears about them, he spots an opportunity to bring down those walls…

The Devils is extraordinary on so many levels. Russell’s screenplay (adapted from the play by John Whiting) is wonderfully eloquent and clearly shows the extremes of what can happen when religious hysteria and superstition go head-to-head with power and political ambition. The set design by Derek Jarman (long before he himself embarked on a dazzling career as a film director) looks absolutely astonishing. Shirley Russell’s costume designs, David Watkins’ cinematography and Peter Maxwell Davies’ score all contribute to the vibrant and tangible nature of the film. Though Russell would go on the create many more excellent features, even finding ways to achieve impressive results long after the days when he could command decent budgets (reduced to making them in his garage towards the end), this is undoubtedly his masterpiece.

The performances too are exemplary. Redgrave portrays Jeanne’s inner demons with a series of sly glances and disturbing giggles, while Sutton is eloquently despicable as the oily Baron de Loubardement. It’s also interesting to see Reed – who latterly became better known as a hellraiser than as an actor – turning in a powerful and nuanced performance as Grandier, a man who was certainly a hypocritical philanderer, but surely didn’t deserve the awful fate that befell him. The supporting cast is made up of a whole host of actors who went on to achieve fame in differing ways. (Yes, that really is Brian Murphy as one of the leering ‘physicians’, who would go on to TV infamy as George in George and Mildred!) And of course, there’s Murray Melvin as Father Mignon, a far cry from the role in A Taste of Honey that first brought him to public attention but totally commanding as a conflicted fellow priest.

So, I have waited more than fifty years to see this film in the form that Ken Russell wanted it to be seen. Is it worth the wait? Yes. And I urge anybody reading this to go and see it for themselves, either in the 4K re-release or – if possible – in 35mm, where the film’s full vibrancy can be fully appreciated.

5 Stars

Philip Caveney

Godzilla Minus Zero

06/11/26

Cineworld, Edinburgh

2023’s Godzilla Minus One was a bit of a triumph. In what is officially the world’s longest-running cinema franchise, writer-director Takashi Yamazaki achieved an astute reinvention simply by realising that, if he devoted as much screen time to the story’s human characters as its mythical beasts, he might elevate it to something more than just another action flick. (As I observed in my review, it took them a mere seventy years to come to this realisation). GM1 fared well at the box office and even won an Oscar for its special effects, so of course there would have to be a sequel.

Hence Godzilla Minus Zero, which – if nothing else – proves that making something bigger, louder and a bit longer doesn’t necessarily make it better.

It’s 1949 and there’s been no sign of Godzilla since he disappeared into the depths of Sagami Bay at the end of GM1. Former failed-kamikaze pilot, Kōichi (Ryûnosuke Kamiki), has now married Noriko (Miname Himabe) and the two of them are caring for their adopted daughter, Akiko (Sae Nagatani). They are understandably looking forward to a quieter life – though Noriko is suffering from the after-effects of her brush with Godzilla and appears to have inherited some of the creature’s chromosomes. She now has scales poking through the flesh of her neck and a really dodgy-looking right eye.

But there’s a new monster on the scene, a dragon-like flying creature dubbed Ghidorah by the powers that be. The film opens with the creature attacking Matsumoto city and pretty much destroying it. Meanwhile, Kenji Noda (Hidetaka Yoshioda) is heading up a ‘disaster response team’ and, when he starts looking for an experienced pilot to handle all those dangerous flying missions, Kōichi is the obvious first choice. Biologist Kanji (Min Tanaka), who nurtures awful memories of the deaths of his family at Hiroshima, thinks he has come up with an exclusive new method of influencing – and possibly controlling – Godzilla. Of course, the titular kaiju eventually shows up again and everything comes down to a climactic battle between the two gigantic beasties…

While GM0 features similar dazzling special effects sequences to its predecessor, the storyline here feels more tortuous and there are too many scenes of scientists adjusting dials and shouting orders into telephones. And while Akiko is every bit as cute as she was in the first movie, we do seem to spend a little too much time watching her tantrums.

It probably doesn’t help that the only time slot that works for me is to see the film in a 4DX screening. This has never been my favourite way to watch a movie and, given the action-heavy nature of GM0 it feels a bit like viewing it whilst riding a rollercoaster. As the carnage unfolds, I am flung in all directions, pummelled by every impact, blasted with gusts of wind and intermittently sprayed with cold water. (Amusingly, at one point my Apple watch politely asks me if I would like it to record the workout I’m evidently doing.)

To my mind, sequels work best when they offer something different from what went before; sadly, while this does offer two monsters for the price of one, it’s essentially business as usual. Those who enjoyed GM1 will doubtless have a good time with GM0, but for me, it fails to replicate the freshness of its predecessor. And if you have the choice, go for IMAX rather than 4DX.

3.4 stars

Philip Caveney

Wild Horse Nine

05/11/26

Cineworld, Edinburgh.

Director Martin McDonagh has followed an unusual path to filmmaking. He first established his reputation as a playwright in the early 90s with the Leenane trilogy – and more plays followed before he made an assured transition onto the big screen with In Bruges in 2008. This dark but hilarious first feature remains one of my all-time favourite movies. It established the fact that Colin Farrell can act – something he hadn’t really been called upon to do before this point – and, if there’s a more quotable script out there, I’ve yet to discover it.

The films that followed have been variable in quality and I’m sure I’m not the only cinema-goer who favours the Irish-centred projects over the American ones. 2012’s Seven Psychopaths, for instance, felt like a complete misfire. But McDonagh’s last release, The Banshees of Inisherin, reunited Farrell with his In Bruges partner, Brendan Gleeson, and the result was impressive.

Wild Horse Nine is set in neither Ireland nor the USA. It’s 1973 and CIA hit men Chris (John Malkovich) and Lee (Sam Rockwell) are based in Santiago, quietly meddling with the left-wing government of President Allende, which is now only months away from the military junta that will result in the deaths of thousands of people. Chris has terminal cancer and, as his illness deepens, he’s become prone to shooting his mouth off about all kinds of things that are supposed to be top secret. So the duo’s exasperated boss, MJ (Steve Buscemi), dispatches them to Easter Island (or Rapa Nui, to use its indigenous name).

For one thing, Chris has always expressed an interest in seeing ‘the big heads’ before his time is up. And for another, well, what harm can he possibly do in such a remote location?

Lee is uncomfortably aware that MJ is expecting him to ‘take care’ of Chris if he steps too far out of line; meanwhile, Lee’s serially unfaithful wife Marge (Parker Posey) keeps phoning him up, complaining of mysterious break-ins at the family home. Chris’s outpourings have lately turned towards awkward mentions of one particular CIA operation that took place back in 1963… and the CIA needs him to shut the fuck up.

The film focuses on a dynamic that McDonagh has always been adept at capturing on film: the intense and fluctuating relationships between men with a propensity for violence. Indeed, this does play out like an older, more jaded version of In Bruges, with the two main characters’ roles reversed. Here, it’s the older man who is the most unpredictable, the younger who is required to step up and take care of any problems. Some of the scenes play out like alternative versions of what has gone before, as if McDonagh’s own advancing years have afforded him a new perspective.

Both Malkovich and Rockwell are in great form and much of their dialogue – while not quite of the insanely rollicking calibre of In Bruges – is acerbically funny. The female roles are less well served. Posey doesn’t have an awful lot to do as the awful Marge, though Mariana di Girolamo as young student, Monika, does at least manage to make the most of her scenes – and there’s a vague father-daughter vibe between Monika and Chris that adds a little warmth to what is essentially a cold-hearted tale. Cinematographer Ben Davis captures Rapa Nui in all its weird majesty and the 1970s period stylings are convincingly done. For my money this is a step down from Banshees but a step up from 3 Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri. How well it will fare at the box office is another matter.

Oh, and for nit-picky types like me, I’ll ask one question. Rifle and suitcase? Could the former really fit inside the latter? Answers on a postcard, please.

4.3 stars

Philip Caveney